72 - Chris Chiogioji (2015)
62 - Gavin Serwer (2022)
59 - Scott Atwell (Attack) (2003)
57 - Andrew Cavanaugh (2023)
57 - Nick Towson (Attack) (2003)
55 - Andrew Cavanaugh (2024)
53 - Andrew Cavanaugh (2025)
53 - Michael Begley (Midfield) (2011)
52 - Andrew Bergesen (2025)
50 - Gavin Serwer (2021)
49 - Andrew Stahley (2022)
45 - Charlie Matusek (2021)
45 - Patrick Curran (Attack) (2003)
45 - Nick Towson (Attack) (2002)
44 - Kyle Johnson (2009)
44 - Nick Towson (Attack) (2001)
42 - Jack Heagy (2025)
42 - Kyle Johnson (Attack) (2008)
41 - Cael Comstock (2023)
41 - Andrew Bergesen (2024)
41 - Michael Crooks (Midfield) (2014)
41 - EJ Audibert (Midfield - Attack) (2014)
40 - Jack Heagy (2024)
40 - Jake Guiffre (Midfield) (2015)
40 - Kevin Laskin (2009)
39 - Eric Lederer (Attack) (1998)
39 - Greg Sessa (Attack) (1999)
38 - Keith Milli (Attack) (1999)
37 - Michael Begley (Midfield) (2009)
37 - Nick Gallagher (2017)
37 - Kevin Laskin (2008)
37 - Brian Hack (midfield) (2011)
36 - Sam Cromwell (Attack) (2011)
36 - Scott Atwell (Attack) (2002)
36 - Eric Braker (2017)
36 - Chris Voorhees (2013)
35 - Griffin Paquin (2012)
35 - Jackson Derrick (2022)
35 - Mike Towson (Attack) (2005)
35 - Garrett Anderson (Midfield) (2006)
32 - Dylan Hubbard (Midfield) (2011)
32 - Mike Anderson (Attack) (2004)
32 - Greg Sessa (Attack) (1998)
31 - Greg Sessa (Attack) (1997)
31 - Kyle Johnson (Attack) (2007)
30 - Kyle Johnson (Attack) (2006)
30 - Jackson Downs (2015)
30 - Scott Atwell (Attack) (2001)
29 - Eric Lederer (Attack) (1999)
29 - Jake Guiffre (midfield) (2014)
28 - Keith Milli (Attack) (1998)
28 - Mike Towson (Attack) (2006)
27 - Grant Fricke (2014)
27 - Kyle Atwell (Midfield) (2003)
26 - Ryan Subt (Midfield) (1997)
26 - Steven Anderson (Attack/Midfield) (2006)
26 - Nick Towson (Attack) (2000)
25 - Andrew Bolton (Midfield) (2001)
25 - Kevin Laskin (Attack) (2010)
25 - Steven Anderson (Midfield) (2007)
25 - Jeremy Shannon (Midfield) (1999)
25 - Chris Voorhees (2012)
25 - Matt Cromwell (2012)
24 - Kyle Atwell (Midfield) (2002)
23 - Brandon Lohmeyer (Attack) (1995 - MCPLL Club)
23 - Chris Chiogioji (2013)
23 - Wes McMahon (Attack) (2006)
22 - Max Dechter (2014)
22 - Patrick Lavay (Attack) (2001)
21 - Brian Hack (2010)
21 - Garrett Anderson (Midfield) (2007)
21 - Chris Chiogioji (2013)
21 - Eric Braker (2016)
21 - Nick Dunwoody (2016)
20 - Luke Logan (midfield) (2014)
20 - Michael Feeney (2017)
20 - Patrick Curran (Attack) (2002)
20 - Michael Crooks (2012)
20 - Michael Schulz (Attack) (2007)
20 - Scott Fricke (2009)
20 - Michael Begley (2010)
20 - Scott Fricke (Attack) (2010)